Online Beer Scores logo

Add a Beer Add a Commercial Beer Judge a Beer View a Scoresheet My Activity About Blog

Scoresheets for Horny Goat Brewing Co. Chocolate Peanut Butter Porter

23A Specialty Beer

Average Score / 50
Scored by

Judge: Malcolm (
Judge Qualification: Rank Pending
Entry ID: 97327858
Style: 23A Specialty Beer
Beer Info:
Descriptors: Alcoholic Astringent
Bottle Inspection:
Bottle Comments: ok

Malt - None. Hops - None. Esters/ Phenols - Medium amts of vanilla.
Med-High amts of a chocolate. But chocolate syrup vs cocoa powder or choc malt. On initial pour the peanut butter aroma was that of natural coarsely refined PB. As the beer warmed that faded into mostly cloying chocolate syrup.
6 / 12

Beer is a dark chocolatey brown. Opaque. Head is light tan with small dense bubble. Poured large but faded to 1/4" inch and then lasted.
3 / 3

Malt - low chocolate bready flavor. med-low roast. Hops - None. Ferment - no prominent ester profile. Blance is to the chocolate but finishes with a medium and mildly harsh bitterness. As the beer warmed a tiny bit of PB character is there but i had to hunt for it.
11 / 20

Body - med-high with a slick and viscous feel. Carbonation is medium. Enough to provide some prickle on the tongue. Mildly warming (6.5% abv). No astringency. Does leave a drying sensation despite its body - could be due to the chocolate, or hop bitterness.
3 / 5

Decent beverage for the fan of extreme flavored beers. No flaws to speak of as to quality but the recipe and balance (as noted above) made it hard to finish. Both flavor and aroma are 80/20 Choc/PB and little to no beer character.
5 / 10

Total Score: 28 / 50

Style Accuracy: 3 / 5
Technical Merit: 4 / 5
Intangibles: 2 / 5

< Back to Commercial Beer Listing