Online Beer Scores logo

Add a Beer Add a Commercial Beer Judge a Beer View a Scoresheet My Activity About Blog

Scoresheets for St Amand Biere de Garde

16D Biere de Garde

Average Score 14 / 50
Scored by 2 People


Score Sheet #1 - Judged by a Provisional Judge judge and scored 28

Judge: Brian Robbins (b-robbins@comcast.net)
Judge Qualification: Provisional Judge
Entry ID: 80327645
Style: 16D Biere de Garde
Beer Info:
Descriptors: Alcoholic Estery Musty Oxidized
Bottle Inspection: All Good
Bottle Comments:

Aroma:
Pronounced sweet almond and sherry oxidized aroma. Rich bready malt aroma, toasted nuts. Low noble hop aroma. Some toffee deep caramel. Low ripe plum esters. Light alcohol esters.
4 / 12

Appearance:
Deep golden light amber, brilliant clarity, beautiful. Moderate head of off white fine foam that drops quickly, but leaves a small ring of persistent foam. Faint alcohol legs are evident
3 / 3

Flavor:
Rich bready complex malt with toasted, toffee and caramel. Low spicy hop flavor, moderate bitterness from hops and alcohol. Oxidation is apparent, but not overly unpleasant. Balanced to malt sweetness. Light plum and dark ripe atone fruits.
11 / 20

Mouthfeel:
Moderate+ carbonation. Medium body with moderate alcohol warmth (ok). Alcohol lends a dry warmth that persists through the finish
5 / 5

Overall:
A good beer which would be outstanding if not for the oxidation issue. Despite this, still enjoyable thanks to the outstanding malt character. Watch introduction of air post fermentation, particularly during packaging. Store appropriately and drink within a reasonable amount of time
5 / 10

Total Score: 28 / 50

Style Accuracy: 5 / 5
Technical Merit: 2 / 5
Intangibles: 4 / 5

Score Sheet #2 - Judged by a Honorary Grand Master judge and scored 0

Judge: Lateisha (72d28kcsp8@mail.com)
Judge Qualification: Honorary Grand Master
Entry ID: 80327645
Style: 16D Biere de Garde
Beer Info: Gf4HL0Bcyta8
Descriptors:
Bottle Inspection:
Bottle Comments: Good thing this dress is above the knee because that makes it good for the flying helicopter kick, a wicked martial arts move, which is just the thing for sl-eubromobthed comments. You look gorgeous in both the Karen Millen and the pinafore - those colours are wonderful. Jean's post was like Nigella Lawson except with clothes.

Aroma:
Good thing this dress is above the knee because that makes it good for the flying helicopter kick, a wicked martial arts move, which is just the thing for sl-eubromobthed comments. You look gorgeous in both the Karen Millen and the pinafore - those colours are wonderful. Jean's post was like Nigella Lawson except with clothes.
0 / 12

Appearance:
Good thing this dress is above the knee because that makes it good for the flying helicopter kick, a wicked martial arts move, which is just the thing for sl-eubromobthed comments. You look gorgeous in both the Karen Millen and the pinafore - those colours are wonderful. Jean's post was like Nigella Lawson except with clothes.
0 / 3

Flavor:
Good thing this dress is above the knee because that makes it good for the flying helicopter kick, a wicked martial arts move, which is just the thing for sl-eubromobthed comments. You look gorgeous in both the Karen Millen and the pinafore - those colours are wonderful. Jean's post was like Nigella Lawson except with clothes.
0 / 20

Mouthfeel:
Good thing this dress is above the knee because that makes it good for the flying helicopter kick, a wicked martial arts move, which is just the thing for sl-eubromobthed comments. You look gorgeous in both the Karen Millen and the pinafore - those colours are wonderful. Jean's post was like Nigella Lawson except with clothes.
0 / 5

Overall:
Good thing this dress is above the knee because that makes it good for the flying helicopter kick, a wicked martial arts move, which is just the thing for sl-eubromobthed comments. You look gorgeous in both the Karen Millen and the pinafore - those colours are wonderful. Jean's post was like Nigella Lawson except with clothes.
0 / 10

Total Score: 0 / 50

Style Accuracy: 5 / 5
Technical Merit: 1 / 5
Intangibles: 5 / 5


< Back to Commercial Beer Listing